Appeals & extraordinary writs · a pro-se ladder

If you lost and want to keep fighting, there is an order you have to climb — trial loss → appeal → reconsideration → state post-conviction → discretionary review → the Supreme Court → federal habeas → the extraordinary writs (mandamus and its cousins). Take them out of order and you can permanently burn a later option. Pick your jurisdiction, then walk the ladder. This is legal information and a fill-in-the-blank tool — not legal advice.

1 · Your jurisdiction

State, DC, or federal — and the court level. This drives which deadlines and rules apply.

The exhaustion ladder — climb it in order

✓ a step you have marked done · ⚠ a gated step whose earlier rungs are not marked done · steps are numbered in the order you must climb them.

1 Direct appeal

The direct appeal is the ordinary, first-as-of-right challenge to a final judgment. You ask a higher court to review the trial record for legal error — you generally do NOT get to add new evidence. It is the base of the ladder: almost everything above it assumes you took, or gave up, this step first.

Open this step →

2 Motion for reconsideration / new trial

A motion asking the SAME court that ruled to reconsider — for legal error, or a new trial (in a criminal case, often on newly discovered evidence). It is filed back in the trial court, not up the ladder.

Open this step →

3 State post-conviction / state habeas ⚠

A separate (collateral) proceeding in state court to raise things a direct appeal could not — most often ineffective assistance of counsel, newly discovered evidence, or a constitutional violation that lives outside the trial record. Every state has its own vehicle (post-conviction relief, a state habeas petition, a "coram nobis"-style motion, etc.).

Open this step →

4 Discretionary review (state supreme court) ⚠

After an intermediate appellate court rules, you ask the state’s highest court to review it. In most states this is DISCRETIONARY — the court chooses whether to take the case (a petition for review / petition for discretionary review), it is not an appeal of right.

Open this step →

5 Certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court ⚠

A petition for a writ of certiorari asks the U.S. Supreme Court to review a final judgment of a state court of last resort (on a federal question) or a U.S. Court of Appeals. It is almost entirely discretionary — the Court grants a tiny fraction of petitions.

Open this step →

6 Federal habeas corpus (§ 2254 / § 2255) exhaust first⚠

A collateral attack in FEDERAL court on a conviction or sentence that violates the U.S. Constitution or federal law. State prisoners use 28 U.S.C. § 2254; federal prisoners use a § 2255 motion in the sentencing court. It is not a second appeal — the review is narrow and deferential to the state courts.

Open this step →

7 Writ of mandamus (§ 1361 / All Writs Act / state) last resort⚠

An extraordinary writ ordering a government officer, court, or agency to perform a clear, non-discretionary DUTY it is refusing to do (or, in aid of jurisdiction, to stop exceeding its authority). In federal district court it rests on 28 U.S.C. § 1361; appellate mandamus rests on the All Writs Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1651. To compel a federal AGENCY specifically, the everyday vehicle is the APA: 5 U.S.C. § 706(1) lets a court "compel agency action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed."

Open this step →

8 Writ of coram nobis ⚠

An ancient writ to correct a fundamental error in a case where the sentence has already been served, so habeas (which requires being "in custody") is unavailable — for example, to clear a conviction still causing collateral consequences. In federal court it is recognized under the All Writs Act: United States v. Morgan, 346 U.S. 502 (1954).

Open this step →

8 Writ of prohibition ⚠

Mandamus’s mirror image: instead of ordering a lower court/official to ACT, prohibition orders it to STOP — to refrain from exceeding its jurisdiction or authority. Like mandamus it is an extraordinary writ under the All Writs Act (or a state equivalent).

Open this step →

8 Writ of quo warranto

A special writ challenging a person’s RIGHT to hold a public office or exercise a public franchise — "by what authority?" It is usually brought by a government attorney (an Attorney General or, federally, the U.S. Attorney), not a private individual, and it stands apart from the appeal/habeas ladder rather than on top of it.

Open this step →

Select a step on the ladder above to open its teaching, deadlines, required fields, and the governing statutes and cases.

Local ordinances — read them yourself

If your issue is a city or county ordinance, you can pull the actual text here and work through it yourself (or with an AI helper). These are finders and official code portals — we link where the codes live, not a guess at any one ordinance’s URL.

Find your city / county code

Municode Library

The largest host of municipal & county codes — pick your state, then your city/county to read its ordinances.

American Legal Publishing — Code Library

The other major municipal-code host; many mid-size and large cities publish here.

General Code / eCode360

A third national code host, common in the Northeast and Midwest.

Law Library of Congress — U.S. State & Local Government

Official Library of Congress research guide to finding state and local law.

Cornell LII — Municipal / local law

Plain-language background on how municipal ordinances work and where they sit under state law.

Example jurisdiction code portals

New York City — Administrative Code & Rules

Example of a city’s own code/rules portal (NYC).

City of Los Angeles — Municipal Code

Example of a large-city code hosted on a national platform.

AI-generated — not legal advice. Everything this tool produces is AI-generated legal INFORMATION and fill-in-the-blank structure. It is not legal advice, it is not a lawyer, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines, page limits, and procedures vary by court and change over time — verify every specific in your court’s own rules before you rely on it.

What to do with it: take the draft or notes to a licensed attorney, a legal-aid clinic, or your court’s self-help center; and file through the court’s official system. Most courts use an e-filing portal (federal courts: PACER/CM-ECF; many state courts have their own e-file site) and publish free pro-se packets and clerk help lines. When a deadline or a right is on the line, get a human lawyer — a federal-defender or public-defender office for criminal/habeas matters.

Frequently asked questions

What is the "exhaustion ladder" for appeals?

It is the fixed order you must challenge a court loss in: direct appeal, then a motion for reconsideration or new trial, then state post-conviction/state habeas, then discretionary review in the state supreme court, then certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court, then federal habeas corpus, and only then the extraordinary writs like mandamus. Taking a step out of order can permanently forfeit ("burn") a later option.

Why can filing federal habeas too early hurt me?

Federal habeas (28 U.S.C. § 2254 for state prisoners, § 2255 for federal) requires that you first exhaust state remedies (28 U.S.C. § 2254(b)(1)). Filing before you finish the state process can get the petition dismissed, the AEDPA one-year clock (28 U.S.C. § 2244(d)(1)) can run out, a claim can be procedurally defaulted, and a second petition needs the court of appeals’ permission. Get a lawyer or a federal-defender office before filing.

When is a writ of mandamus appropriate?

Mandamus is a last resort after ordinary appeals fail and an official or agency still refuses to perform a clear, non-discretionary duty, when no other adequate remedy exists. It rests on statute now — 28 U.S.C. § 1361, the All Writs Act (§ 1651), and for agencies the APA (5 U.S.C. § 706(1)).

Does this tool give legal advice?

No. It is AI-generated legal information and a fill-in-the-blank scaffold — not legal advice and not a lawyer. Deadlines and rules vary by court and change; verify every specific in your court’s own rules, and take a draft to a licensed attorney, a legal-aid clinic, or your court’s self-help center.